How to Make Grilled Cheese in a Toaster Oven

Rate this post

If you’re still unfamiliar with your toaster oven or are curious about what it can and cannot cook, I highly suggest making a grilled cheese sandwich.

The sandwich comes out deliciously brown and grilled in all the right spots because to the uniform and continuous heat.

The objective of having a toaster oven is now unsupervised cooking.

I know that with certain models, individuals have difficulties getting the bottom half of the bread toaster to work correctly; in this situation, I suggest just sitting down and monitoring how long it takes to cook properly.

You only need to do it once.

Also, if the Bake option does not work, try Pizza.

If you’re not a fan of grilled cheese, it’s most likely due to your bread of choice.

You can’t go wrong with sourdough or multigrain bread instead of the sticky white bread from 7-Eleven.

Which cheese is best for a grilled cheese sandwich?

How to Make Grilled Cheese in a Toaster Oven

In terms of ingredients, I normally stick to sharp cheddar, but if you want to mix things up a little, here are my top three picks:

  1. Havarti: dissolves beautifully. Combine it with cheddar for a heavenly gooey-salty combo.
  2. Muenster has a creamy texture, a fantastic flavor, and melts well. Pro tip: on the interior of the bread, apply a little Dijon or coarse mustard.
  3. Smoke gouda.

As strange as it seems, I know folks who propose adding bacon, broccoli, or even sweet potatoes to the cheese, but remember, if you add items to the cheese, it’s no longer a grilled cheese sandwich, but a melt.

What kind of bread is best for a grilled cheese sandwich?

How to Make Grilled Cheese in a Toaster Oven

It is entirely up to you whatever bread you select for your grilled cheese sandwich.

However, we suggest choosing a thick bread, such as sourdough or ciabatta.

This allows the cheese to melt evenly and keeps the bread from becoming soggy.

However, if you want to try something new, you may use rye bread, whole wheat bread, or pumpernickel bread.

Just make sure the bread is thickly cut so it doesn’t become too soggy.

What are some other ways to make a grilled cheese sandwich?

Here are a few suggestions for how to spice up your grilled cheese sandwich:

For a healthy twist, add some spinach, arugula, or kale to your grilled cheese.

Change up the cheese: In your grilled cheese sandwich, try a different variety of cheese. Cheddar, brie, and goat cheese are all excellent choices.

Add some extras: For a nice and substantial lunch, top your grilled cheese with tomatoes, onions, or peppers.

A traditional sandwich that is always a hit is grilled cheese.

So, if you’re seeking for a quick and easy method to prepare grilled cheese, keep reading for instructions on how to cook it in a toaster oven.

You’ll have the ideal grilled cheese for every occasion with only a few ingredients and a little time.

How do you know when grilled cheese is done?

When the cheese is melted and bubbling and the bread is golden brown, your grilled cheese is ready.

If desired, insert a knife into the middle of the sandwich to ensure that the cheese is completely melted.

Can you make grilled cheese in a toaster oven without butter?

Yes, you can prepare grilled cheese without using butter in a toaster oven.

If you want a healthy alternative, consider olive oil or avocado oil.

You may also use mayonnaise if you’re not concerned about calories.

Simply spread it over the exterior of the bread to prevent it from becoming too soggy.

How to Store Grilled Cheese using Toaster Oven

It would be a shame to have a delicious, visually appealing Grilled Cheese and not know how to keep it.

Luckily, with a toaster oven, you can have both!

Here’s how to keep your grilled cheese fresh in the toaster oven until you’re ready to reheat and eat it.

  1. To begin, ensure sure your toaster oven is clean and dry. Any moisture causes the bread to get soggy and prevents the cheese from melting and bubbling.
  2. Place your grilled cheese on a piece of aluminum foil to finish. To keep the cheese gooey and tasty, make sure it’s facing up.
  3. Fold the aluminum foil edges around the sandwich to completely cover it. This will keep the heat inside and the cheese melted.
  4. Finally, put the foil-wrapped sandwich in the toaster oven and bake for 10 minutes, or until the cheese is melted and bubbling.

As a result, your Grilled Cheese will be kept and warmed in the most delicious manner imaginable in a toaster oven!

Nutrition Facts of Grilled Cheese using Toaster Oven

Grilled Cheese in the Toaster Oven is full of wonderful taste with a hint of naughtiness.

Here’s why it’s much superior than the packet mix version.

  • Calories: 443
  • Fat: 28 grams
  • Saturated Fat: 16 grams
  • Cholesterol: 86 milligrams
  • Sodium: 710 milligrams
  • Carbohydrates: 30 grams
  • Fiber: 2 grams
  • Sugar: 5 grams
  • Protein: 17 grams

Grilled Cheese has a high calorie count, but it is well worth it.

The meal is high in protein and fiber, which will keep you feeling filled for longer.

Because of the high saturated fat content, it is not the healthiest choice if you are monitoring your waistline.

However, if you want to treat yourself, this is a wonderful option.

So, is it worth the calories to eat grilled cheese? Yes, in our view!

The meal is flavorful and will fulfill your hunger. Grilled Cheese is a traditional comfort dish that is ideal for a cold winter day.

You’ll feel right at home with the toasted bread, gooey cheese, and crispy bacon.

It’s also a lot simpler to construct than you would believe. So, why not give it a shot?

What to Serve with Grilled Cheese using Toaster Oven

It might be difficult to come up with great and fulfilling dinner ideas while cooking for one. But don’t worry!

The basic grilled cheese sandwich has come to the rescue. And it’s much more accessible when prepared in a toaster oven.

But what do you serve with your grilled cheese?

A soup or salad is usually a wonderful choice, but we have some more suggestions for you. What about adding roasted tomatoes or some bacon on the side?

You could even go all out and prepare a grilled cheese sandwich feast!

Tomato Soup

For good reason, grilled cheese and tomato soup are a traditional combo.

The soup complements the cheese, crunchy sandwich well.

It’s also simple to cook in a toaster oven. Simply roast some tomatoes with garlic and olive oil before pureeing them into a smooth soup.

Serve with a grilled cheese sandwich on the side for a tasty and quick dinner.

Roasted Bacon

When it comes to grilled cheese, bacon is always a solid option.

But why not take it up a notch by roasting it?

Roasted bacon is crispy and delicious, making it ideal for topping a grilled cheese sandwich.

Simply arrange bacon pieces on a baking sheet and bake at 400 degrees F for 15-20 minutes. Then, serve your grilled cheese with a couple slices of tomato and enjoy!

Grilled Cheese Sandwich Feast

If you’re feeling really adventurous, make a full-fledged grilled cheese sandwich feast.

Grilled cheese, roasted tomatoes, bacon, and soup are all included in this dinner. To begin, toast the tomatoes and bacon in the toaster oven.

Make your grilled cheese sandwiches next. Put everything on a plate and serve!

We believe you’ll like it regardless of what you serve with your grilled cheese sandwich.

So fire up your toaster


  • Two slices of sourdough or multigrain bread
  • Cheddar or your choice of cheese
  • Softened butter or light mayonnaise (low calorie but just as tasty)


  1. Preheat your toaster oven to 425 degrees Fahrenheit on the Bake setting.
  2. On the outside of your bread, spread butter or light mayonnaise.
  3. Spread cheese on one piece of bread, then top with the second slice, butter side up.
  4. Place the bread in the prepared pan. Cook until golden brown, approximately 5 minutes.
  5. Remove it gently, flip it with a spatula, and return it to the oven for another 3-4 minutes, or until the other side is golden as well.
  6. Cool, cut and enjoy.

I’ve put up the recipe in a printable booklet for you once again. I hope you like it:

Can you Make Grilled Cheese in a Regular Toaster?


See my post about it here.



PS. Check out my other recipes as well!


How do you make grilled cheese in a toaster?

Spread the butter on one piece of bread and place it on top of the foil. Top with the second piece of bread after adding the shredded cheese. Place the foil-wrapped sandwich gently in the toaster for 3-4 minutes, or until the bread is golden brown and the cheese has melted.

Can you grill in a toaster oven?

Food may be grilled or baked. This sort of oven comes in a variety of sizes, which determines what may be cooked in it.An OTG can reheat, stay warm, and grill food.

Do you make a grilled cheese in a toaster?

Making Grilled Cheese in the Toaster
Step 1: Take a toaster and flip it over.
Step 2: Gather some bread and cheese.
Step 3: Spread some cheese on one slice of bread.
Step 4: Place the Toaster Slices in it.
Step 5: Insert the bread slices by clicking the lever.
Place your plate in front of the toaster.

What temperature do you cook a sandwich in a toaster oven?

Preheat the toaster oven to 450 degrees Fahrenheit (232 degrees Celsius).

Set the oven temperature and let it to heat up while you build the sandwich. You won’t need to prepare a baking sheet since you’ll be placing the sandwich right on the heated rack inside the oven.

How long does it take cheese to melt in toaster oven?

The toaster oven is the ideal method to reheat grilled cheese. Your chilly leftover sandwich will be warm, melty, and wonderful in only a few minutes. Preheat the toaster oven to 350 degrees Fahrenheit. Place the sandwich on a baking pan in the toaster oven and cook for 3-4 minutes on each side.

Should I toast my bread before making grilled cheese?

The Best Grilled Cheese Bread

Toast your bread first for the finest results. A brief toast can help your bread produce the desired golden edges and juicy crunch. It will also help keep the bread from becoming soggy, regardless of how many contents you add.

What Cannot be cooked in a toaster oven?

Here are certain foods (and utensils) that you should avoid using in your toaster oven.
Foods that are fatty or greasy.”No, I would say.
Seeds and nuts left unattended.
Bakeware made of glass or ceramic that is not broiler-safe.
Paper, wood, and plastic are all acceptable materials.

Why does it say not to cook in toaster oven?

We do not advocate utilizing toaster ovens since they vary greatly in size, heat distribution, distance from heating element, and insulation. The product would be too near to the heating source, which might result in a fire.

What is the disadvantage of a toaster oven?

It’s not the best option for just toasting bread pieces for breakfast.
Toaster ovens range in price from roughly $25 to $250, making them somewhat pricey when compared to a standard toaster.
It’s a loud machine.

Can you put aluminum foil in a toaster oven?

Most manufacturers recommend using care while covering cookware and plates with aluminum foil. If the foil is not firmly fastened to the pan, it may come into touch with the heating elements (or walls) of the oven, causing overheating and an increased danger of fire.

Recommended Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *